BMW i5 and 5-Series Forum

Post Reply
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread
      03-11-2009, 01:47 PM   #1
rotaz
Captain
rotaz's Avatar
61
Rep
698
Posts

Drives: GT3, 4Runner S/C
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: SF Bay

iTrader: (0)

07 997 Carrera S or E92 M3?

I can pretty much get a good used 07 997 Carrera S for just about the same price as a E92 M3.

Carrera S
Pros:
It's a P-Car!
better gas mileage
looks hawt!
better handling?

Cons:
Maintenance
slower in a straight line

M3
Pros:
Newer technology
free maintenance for 4 yrs/50k

cons:
mpg sucks!


Anyone want to add to this list?

Any thoughts or comments?
__________________
|Arrived 12/14/06| JP Vizage Kit| Gone 4/4/09 |
Appreciate 0
      03-11-2009, 01:51 PM   #2
NewSong
Just another jerk in a hat...
NewSong's Avatar
United_States
121
Rep
1,462
Posts

Drives: 2005 Ford Focus
Join Date: Oct 2008
Location: Irvine

iTrader: (0)

Depends on what you're looking for.

The Carrera is the better sports car. I think the M3 will cost you less in maintenance down the road.

Have you test driven them?
__________________
He brought me up also out of a horrible pit, out of the miry clay, and set my feet upon a rock, and established my goings.

And he hath put a new song in my mouth.
Appreciate 0
      03-11-2009, 01:58 PM   #3
tpipta
First Lieutenant
No_Country
25
Rep
318
Posts

Drives: F15 X5
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: Annapolis, MD

iTrader: (0)

Porsche FTW!

I love my 335i but would give it up in a heart beat if I could have a 911. IMHO I think any 911 will have more heritage and panache than any M3. Again, just my humble opinion.

Either way you will have a fantastic car!
__________________
2008 AW 335i (Lemon), 2009 AW 335i (Round 2 w/ Basic Mods), 2011 BSM 335i LCI MSport (Sucked), 2010 PW MINI Cooper S Hatchback, 2014 AW M235i, 2017 X5
Appreciate 0
      03-11-2009, 01:59 PM   #4
335timb
New Member no longer
United_States
3
Rep
42
Posts

Drives: '07 335i Sedan
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Topeka, KS

iTrader: (0)

Other considerations:

Do you need a functional rear seat?
Do you care about perception? Will friends/co-workers see you as arrogant if you're in a Porsche? (As opposed to a BMW...I know, kinda silly...)
3rd car or daily driver? Will it see much duty in foul weather?

I just see the M3 as 90% of the fun of the Carrera, but with MUCH greater practicality. So, DD?--->M3. Extra/3rd car?--->Carrera.
Appreciate 0
      03-11-2009, 02:14 PM   #5
machine
is also an E46 Fanatic
machine's Avatar
Canada
40
Rep
538
Posts

Drives: E70 35D
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: Vancouver, BC

iTrader: (0)

I would get the porsche, its a porsche.
Appreciate 0
      03-11-2009, 02:34 PM   #6
Sticky
Banned
United_States
79
Rep
2,240
Posts

Drives: E92 Jerez DCT M3
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Anaheim Hills / Malibu

iTrader: (0)

It's a P car does not mean as much when you can get P SUV's and Sedans these days.

Plus, an 07 is an old P car, vs. the new 997S is a more difficult decision. With an 07, simple decision in my view.
Appreciate 0
      03-11-2009, 03:10 PM   #7
rotaz
Captain
rotaz's Avatar
61
Rep
698
Posts

Drives: GT3, 4Runner S/C
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: SF Bay

iTrader: (0)

It's definatly not going to be a DD, I will have a DD (honda) for sure.

I haven't test driven the 997S yet, but driven the E92 M3 both 6MT and DCT.
__________________
|Arrived 12/14/06| JP Vizage Kit| Gone 4/4/09 |
Appreciate 0
      03-11-2009, 03:30 PM   #8
E92AXM
First Lieutenant
E92AXM's Avatar
124
Rep
313
Posts

Drives: 335i
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Fl

iTrader: (0)

On looks subjectively i choose e92 m3. Every time i see one i cant look away, plus huge aftermarket. Eve though a Porsche is a Porsche unless its like a Turbo, gt3rs , gt2. They just don't catch my eye. They all look the same to me until you step it up to the big dogs. Performance with both is good. Best bet is to drive both then decide.
Appreciate 0
      03-11-2009, 03:35 PM   #9
rotaz
Captain
rotaz's Avatar
61
Rep
698
Posts

Drives: GT3, 4Runner S/C
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: SF Bay

iTrader: (0)

Quote:
Originally Posted by SiNiStErE92 View Post
On looks subjectively i choose e92 m3. Every time i see one i cant look away, plus huge aftermarket. Eve though a Porsche is a Porsche unless its like a Turbo, gt3rs , gt2. They just don't catch my eye. They all look the same to me until you step it up to the big dogs. Performance with both is good. Best bet is to drive both then decide.
I actually agree w/ you on this...u only notice the turbos, GT2/3 on the road...
__________________
|Arrived 12/14/06| JP Vizage Kit| Gone 4/4/09 |
Appreciate 0
      03-11-2009, 03:42 PM   #10
E92AXM
First Lieutenant
E92AXM's Avatar
124
Rep
313
Posts

Drives: 335i
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Fl

iTrader: (0)

Another thing to think about is. Would you be purchasing M3 brand new? Exactly how you would want it, or getting a used 07 carrera s . Hoping to find one with warranty still in tact, low miles, right color combo , etc.
Appreciate 0
      03-11-2009, 03:53 PM   #11
montreal red
chris
montreal red's Avatar
Canada
292
Rep
12,141
Posts

Drives: White Boat
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: Toronto

iTrader: (31)

i was in the same boat... to be honest i'd rather go with the 997 S instead of the M3 but since i could only have 1 daily car, i felt the ability to sit 4 people rather comfortably was quite impt to me so i ended up with the M... but i test drove both... the 997 S is a better car to drive than the M3 imo.
__________________

Current: 2013 F10 M5 & 2016 Mini JCW
2013 GLK350 (gone), 997.1 GT3RS (gone), 2009 WRX STI (gone), e92 M3 (gone)
Appreciate 0
      03-11-2009, 06:04 PM   #12
gonzo
Lieutenant General
gonzo's Avatar
United_States
10337
Rep
14,454
Posts

Drives: as many as possible
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: TeXXXas

iTrader: (0)

911.

Understated is good for my tastes. Classic and classy.

The M3 is a great car too. But not even a coin to flip for me personally. I have not checked in awhile but would think the 911 will always out resale, if you will, the M3.

Really can't go wrong with either IMO. g/l.
Appreciate 0
      03-11-2009, 06:14 PM   #13
mikeokimster
Lieutenant Colonel
208
Rep
1,699
Posts

Drives: e90 jerez m3
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: North Seattle, WA

iTrader: (10)

I don't understand why you are compring a 4 seater to a 2 seater w/ barely a trunk. It is really up to the practicality aspect. Imo two totally different type of cars. One is a heavier GT car with daily livability and good power and handling. The other is a moderate track car with performance intentions only that is great if you are in no need of a functional trunk, road comfort, and practicality.
__________________
Current: 10' E90 Jerez M3 DCT
///Mods: Xpel front clip wrap, Nokya 2500k H8 halos, matte grills, IND reflectors, scoops, MS drop-in, MS track pipes, Dinan exhaust, 240E, ESS tune, BBS CHR, s04 255x35 295x30, KW Clubsports, ceramic pads
Retired: 08' E92 328i JB 6mt 212 rwhp 190 rwtq
Appreciate 0
      03-11-2009, 06:30 PM   #14
Skeptikal12
Private First Class
1
Rep
108
Posts

Drives: none
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: Ontario

iTrader: (0)

Why is this even up for debate?

997S and be done with it.

I wouldn't think twice.
Appreciate 0
      03-11-2009, 06:33 PM   #15
Sniz
Lieutenant General
Sniz's Avatar
689
Rep
10,584
Posts

Drives: e92 335 - gone // e36 M3 turbo
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: Ellicott City, MD

iTrader: (1)

997s crushes the M3 if you ask me....
__________________
Appreciate 0
      03-11-2009, 06:46 PM   #16
wj4
Major General
United_States
358
Rep
7,719
Posts

Drives: E90 manual 335i
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Burbank, CA

iTrader: (8)

Quote:
Originally Posted by Skeptikal12 View Post
Why is this even up for debate?

997S and be done with it.

I wouldn't think twice.
+1,000,000.

My friend has a 997S with the rear bench. Obviously the bench is too small to seat grown adults, but he uses it to carries his briefcase and such. It's his daily driver and after a couple of years of owning it, he still enjoys it much.

Funny that you made this thread..I've been asking my friends the same question..slightly used 997 S or new M3, lol.
Appreciate 0
      03-11-2009, 07:19 PM   #17
rotaz
Captain
rotaz's Avatar
61
Rep
698
Posts

Drives: GT3, 4Runner S/C
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: SF Bay

iTrader: (0)

Quote:
Originally Posted by gonzo View Post
911.

Understated is good for my tastes. Classic and classy.

The M3 is a great car too. But not even a coin to flip for me personally. I have not checked in awhile but would think the 911 will always out resale, if you will, the M3.

Really can't go wrong with either IMO. g/l.
Gonzo, did you ever end up getting that E39 M5?
__________________
|Arrived 12/14/06| JP Vizage Kit| Gone 4/4/09 |
Appreciate 0
      03-11-2009, 07:22 PM   #18
rotaz
Captain
rotaz's Avatar
61
Rep
698
Posts

Drives: GT3, 4Runner S/C
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: SF Bay

iTrader: (0)

What I really want is a 997 GT3, but I can't afford it right now, so I'm trying to compensate with either the 997S or M3.

Again, both cars will not be DD, mainly for fun.

What's typical maintenance on a 911 anyways? Oil change, etc?
__________________
|Arrived 12/14/06| JP Vizage Kit| Gone 4/4/09 |
Appreciate 0
      03-11-2009, 08:28 PM   #19
FASTTOYS
Second Lieutenant
FASTTOYS's Avatar
57
Rep
291
Posts

Drives: Audi R8, X3M, XC60 R-Line
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: USA TEXAS

iTrader: (1)

i HAVE OWNED ALL 3

First all sports cars are droping in value fast. So many deals.
I just left the lot of one of the largest Porsche dealer today. He said last month they sold 9 cars yes 9 cars. Last year i was working a deal on a 07 911s and they let me walk. we were only $800.00 apart. They were shipping cars out of the country because of the exchange rate making a killing.

Ok back on topic.

P-Cars
You can get a great deal on a certified P car. I am working a deal on a 2006 911S 16k miles 51k loaded car & 2002 911 turbo 32k miles 41k. The price gets lower by the day. New they are doing special Financing & incentives
Cert cars 2 years 100k mile which ever comes first.

Maint:
The Porsche: Oil changes cost 120 to 200 per change. regular maint is $$$
The rear main seal leaks 911,911s turbo cars dont have issue. Do not own out of warrentee unless you have $$$ or a friend that can fix it. Rear main seal 1400 to 3000 to fix. They are great cars some times boring to drive because they are so balanced. I have owned 5 P cars.

BMW:

2008 loaded M3 Demo 2000 miles at BMW dealer. never titled. 72k sticker. Price to sell on the tag $52k I think you can get it lower. They have a 2008 black M3 conv 73k sticker they want 53k still can get it lower. I had a M3 on order, I canceled after a 2 hour test drive I was not very impressed with the car. I thought it was heavy and it did not feel fast. I thought the radio and seats were much better than my E46M3 I do like the 4 door M3 its felt better. I guess it a weight thing I exspect a 4 door to be heavy not a 2 door

Maint:
Free unless you do oil changes between service.

One thing I can say, If you have the $$$ and no trade you can get some great car deals. They will get you on the trade .

Good luck
Appreciate 0
      03-11-2009, 08:36 PM   #20
blue2fire
Brigadier General
blue2fire's Avatar
Cayman Islands
235
Rep
4,279
Posts

Drives: BMW 135i
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: Location, Location, Location

iTrader: (8)

The Carrera FTW!
__________________

BMW CCA
Member #420568
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gordon Murray View Post
Being a fan of Honda engines, I requested that they consider building for the F1 a 4.5 liter V10 or V12. I asked, I tried to persuade them, but in the end could not convince them to do it, and the McLaren F1 ended up with a BMW engine.
Appreciate 0
      03-11-2009, 10:00 PM   #21
rotaz
Captain
rotaz's Avatar
61
Rep
698
Posts

Drives: GT3, 4Runner S/C
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: SF Bay

iTrader: (0)

Quote:
Originally Posted by FASTTOYS View Post
First all sports cars are droping in value fast. So many deals.
I just left the lot of one of the largest Porsche dealer today. He said last month they sold 9 cars yes 9 cars. Last year i was working a deal on a 07 911s and they let me walk. we were only $800.00 apart. They were shipping cars out of the country because of the exchange rate making a killing.

Ok back on topic.

P-Cars
You can get a great deal on a certified P car. I am working a deal on a 2006 911S 16k miles 51k loaded car & 2002 911 turbo 32k miles 41k. The price gets lower by the day. New they are doing special Financing & incentives
Cert cars 2 years 100k mile which ever comes first.

Maint:
The Porsche: Oil changes cost 120 to 200 per change. regular maint is $$$
The rear main seal leaks 911,911s turbo cars dont have issue. Do not own out of warrentee unless you have $$$ or a friend that can fix it. Rear main seal 1400 to 3000 to fix. They are great cars some times boring to drive because they are so balanced. I have owned 5 P cars.

BMW:

2008 loaded M3 Demo 2000 miles at BMW dealer. never titled. 72k sticker. Price to sell on the tag $52k I think you can get it lower. They have a 2008 black M3 conv 73k sticker they want 53k still can get it lower. I had a M3 on order, I canceled after a 2 hour test drive I was not very impressed with the car. I thought it was heavy and it did not feel fast. I thought the radio and seats were much better than my E46M3 I do like the 4 door M3 its felt better. I guess it a weight thing I exspect a 4 door to be heavy not a 2 door

Maint:
Free unless you do oil changes between service.

One thing I can say, If you have the $$$ and no trade you can get some great car deals. They will get you on the trade .

Good luck
Thanks for your input...I might go check out my local p-car lot then!

Do you think the 4s is worth the extra $$$ or 2S is good enough?
__________________
|Arrived 12/14/06| JP Vizage Kit| Gone 4/4/09 |
Appreciate 0
      03-11-2009, 10:42 PM   #22
Plan B
Private First Class
Plan B's Avatar
United_States
1
Rep
166
Posts

Drives: 2008 997S / 2007 CaymanS
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: Neither here nor there

iTrader: (0)

997S of course - well, I'm biased. I like the E93 M as well. Drive both, it's a buyers' market.

In regards to a 4S vs 2S...I've tracked both and have driven a 997 Targa extensively on the streets. I would go for a 2S every time. It's much more fun to drive.
__________________

2008 Porsche 911 S 6MT [GT Silver/Cocoa extended leather/sport chrono/loaded]
2007 Porsche Cayman S 6MT [Black/Black extended leather/typical options] Daily Driver
Appreciate 0
Post Reply

Bookmarks


Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off



All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:04 AM.




g60
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
1Addicts.com, BIMMERPOST.com, E90Post.com, F30Post.com, M3Post.com, ZPost.com, 5Post.com, 6Post.com, 7Post.com, XBimmers.com logo and trademark are properties of BIMMERPOST