[ShopVac]

Originally Posted by F30inthe6ix

Murray isn't a terrible goalie - far from it actually - but Andersen is better. Sure, Murray shines in the playoffs, and you've got a couple Cups to show for it, but let's also not forget that 15 years ago you guys were on the verge of folding the organization. Sooner or later your stars will age, and you'll start missing the playoffs. I wonder if even half of your bandwagon is going to stick around for that rebuild. Thank god for revenue sharing, right?

How to start the goalie part - do we want to look historically, where Murray is unproven with 2 cups...winning both cups as a rookie, or do we want to look how Andersen fared with Anaheim? Do we want to look at regular season, or playoffs?

Sophomore jinx, loss of a bunch of D last season, Pens getting shelled in their first few games. A team that was tired for playing twice as many games as everyone else over the last two years. What part do we want to analyze with this? Maybe for all intents and purposes, his glove hand was weighed down by his championship rings. Plausible anyway.

I'd be willing to bet dollar to Tim Horton's donut, that 90% of the league would take Matt Murray over Frederik Andersen any day of the week. You mentioned fantasy in the above post - Murray is higher in everyone's depth chart...look them up if you want.

[F30inthe6ix]

Originally Posted by ShopVac

How to start the goalie part - do we want to look historically, where Murray is unproven with 2 cups...winning both cups as a rookie, or do we want to look how Andersen fared with Anaheim? Do we want to look at regular season, or playoffs?

Sophomore jinx, loss of a bunch of D last season, Pens getting shelled in their first few games. A team that was tired for playing twice as many games as everyone else over the last two years. What part do we want to analyze with this? Maybe for all intents and purposes, his glove hand was weighed down by his championship rings. Plausible anyway.

I'd be willing to bet dollar to Tim Horton's donut, that 90% of the league would take Matt Murray over Frederik Andersen any day of the week. You mentioned fantasy in the above post - Murray is higher in everyone's depth chart...look them up if you want.

Depth Chart

I can't even find Matt Murray on there....can you help me?

[ShopVac]

Originally Posted by F30inthe6ix

LOLLLLLLLLL This guy just said Sheahan is a better two-way player than Kadri.


Dude, I'm done. Have fun with your biased nonsense. You realize that Kadri almost has better stats in a single season than Sheahan does in his career?


Oh, and let me guess, you've got guys in the AHL better than Marner and Matthews, right? At least warn me before you're gonna crack jokes like that...my coffee nearly ended up all over my keyboard from laughing at that.

You're telling me your best 2 way player is only a +2 with scoring 55 points in the season? Do you realize how many goals against he's out for with point production that high. He's a f'ing minus player majority of the time he's out.

Do you really know what a two way player is? Ability to score - ability to from getting scored on. I don't think there's another player on your team (forward wise) that was out for as many goals against than him.

Maybe Toronto hasn't had a good team in so long, that your expectations are just really low. Call me when you win something though...I'm just not sure if I got another 50 years in me.

[Kid Eh]

Originally Posted by F30inthe6ix

Depth Chart

I can't even find Matt Murray on there....can you help me?

He's #84 but well behind Andersen

[Kid Eh]

Originally Posted by ShopVac

You're telling me your best 2 way player is only a +2 with scoring 55 points in the season? Do you realize how many goals against he's out for with point production that high. He's a f'ing minus player majority of the time he's out.

Do you really know what a two way player is? Ability to score - ability to from getting scored on. I don't think there's another player on your team (forward wise) that was out for as many goals against than him.

Maybe Toronto hasn't had a good team in so long, that your expectations are just really low. Call me when you win something though...I'm just not sure if I got another 50 years in me.

Kadri always plays against the other teams top line. Next.

[F30inthe6ix]

Originally Posted by Kid Eh

He's #84 but well behind Andersen

Right about where he deserves to be.

[F30inthe6ix]

Originally Posted by Kid Eh

Kadri always plays against the other teams top line. Next.

Can you believe he's trying to defend this argument of Sheahan > Kadri?

We'll have to revisit this in October...or better yet, in April. Let's hope Sheahan makes the cut out of training camp this season

[Kid Eh]

Originally Posted by F30inthe6ix

Can you believe he's trying to defend this argument of Sheahan > Kadri?

We'll have to revisit this in October...or better yet, in April.

Yes it's statements like that that proves he knows nothing. And to boot I'm a huge Pens fan. I was down there many times when plumbers like Warren Young were in the league because they were lucky enough to play with Lemieux. I'm not a delusional Leafs either. I know their D needs major help but I give credit where credit is due. This guy is just a Pens fanboy with his black and yellow colored glasses on.

[F30inthe6ix]

Originally Posted by Kid Eh

Yes it's statements like that that proves he knows nothing.

I wouldn't say he knows nothing, but his Pens bias is definitely impeding his common sense.

Queue the "haven't won a Cup in 50 years" comeback...that doesn't get old.

[ShopVac]

Originally Posted by F30inthe6ix

Depth Chart

I can't even find Matt Murray on there....can you help me?

Yeah - I can do this to. Over and over.

Goalie Rankings 2018

[ShopVac]

Originally Posted by Kid Eh

Kadri always plays against the other teams top line. Next.

Your guy gets what 13 to 14 minutes a game? At least in his last 5 games I've seen in the playoffs - top lines typically hit over 20 minutes. I find your statement flawed.

As for production - I see your chump a few times a year at most. Maybe Pittsburgh is a bad match up for him and he's a stud with everyone else.

[ShopVac]

Originally Posted by F30inthe6ix

I wouldn't say he knows nothing, but his Pens bias is definitely impeding his common sense.

Queue the "haven't won a Cup in 50 years" comeback...that doesn't get old.

I do believe I've admitted my bias (as late as today). That's what all of us are suppose to do...just like your bias with Toronto.

But, again...my bias is backed up with hardware, your bias is backed up by 50 years of misery.

In any case - I do enjoy engaging hockey talk in July. Thanks - and cheers

[F30inthe6ix]

Originally Posted by ShopVac

I do believe I've admitted my bias (as late as today). That's what all of us are suppose to do...just like your bias with Toronto.

But, again...my bias is backed up with hardware, your bias is backed up by 50 years of misery.

In any case - I do enjoy engaging hockey talk in July. Thanks - and cheers

How many Cups do you have? & how many do we have? Thought so.

Originally Posted by ShopVac

Yeah - I can do this to. Over and over.

Goalie Rankings 2018

One spot ahead, meanwhile in other rankings he's 30 spots below. Average that out and Andersen wins.

[ShopVac]

Originally Posted by F30inthe6ix

How many Cups do you have? & how many do we have? Thought so.

Dude...anyone can win when there's only a few teams in the league...it's more luck of the draw than a Championship. The cups before '67 mean jack shit. Fuck sake, high school teams have a harder run today than the NHL had back then.

Originally Posted by F30inthe6ix

One spot ahead, meanwhile in other rankings he's 30 spots below. Average that out and Andersen wins.

Your great chart with Andersen so high is a banger chart...so what, Andersen gets points and moved up for penalty minutes. Awesome stat

What's your facination with Anaheim`s discarded goods? You're finding gold in someone else's reject...

[F30inthe6ix]

Originally Posted by ShopVac

Dude...anyone can win when there's only a few teams in the league...it's more luck of the draw than a Championship. The cups before '67 mean jack shit. Fuck sake, high school teams have a harder run today than the NHL had back then.




Your great chart with Andersen so high is a banger chart...so what, Andersen gets points and moved up for penalty minutes. Awesome stat

What's your facination with Anaheim`s discarded goods? You're finding gold in someone else's reject...

The whole Cups argument just sounds like someone trying to justify why their team hasn't been as successful as ours historically. Nice try tho. You seem big on statistics, so I'll wait until you've got a real, tangible comeback to that....or I'll wait until you guys bang out back-to-back-to-back-to-back championships...not.

As for "discarded goods"...don't you wish you still had Marc-Andre? Or is he "discarded goods" as well? Another solid argument you've got going here.

[ShopVac]

Originally Posted by F30inthe6ix

The whole Cups argument just sounds like someone trying to justify why their team hasn't been as successful as ours historically. Nice try tho. You seem big on statistics, so I'll wait until you've got a real, tangible comeback to that....or I'll wait until you guys bang out back-to-back-to-back-to-back championships...not.

Feel free to quote me when Toronto accomplishes something with significance...till then, enjoy your faded out back to back to back to back banners that require a good dusting.

[F30inthe6ix]

Originally Posted by ShopVac

Feel free to quote me when Toronto accomplishes something with significance...till then, enjoy your faded out back to back to back to back banners that require a good dusting.

Maybe once your guy is done dusting off the few that you have, he can come and work on our more extensive collection.

Based on your current trajectory, he'll be "discarded goods" in a couple of seasons anyway

[Kid Eh]

Originally Posted by ShopVac

Feel free to quote me when Toronto accomplishes something with significance...till then, enjoy your faded out back to back to back to back banners that require a good dusting.

If it wasn't for Toronto (hockey capital of the world) you'd have fuck all. I can put a team together with current players just from Ontario that would wipe the floor with any team from the USA (we won't bother with just Pennsylvania cuz our womens team would win that). So talk to me when you live in a proper world class city and not a cesspool like Pittsburgh. We get it, you're jealous. That's cool.

https://www.quanthockey.com/nhl/prov...eer-stats.html

[sspade]

Originally Posted by Kid Eh

If it wasn't for Toronto (hockey capital of the world) you'd have fuck all. I can put a team together with current players just from Ontario that would wipe the floor with any team from the USA (we won't bother with just Pennsylvania cuz our womens team would win that). So talk to me when you live in a proper world class city and not a cesspool like Pittsburgh. We get it, you're jealous. That's cool.

https://www.quanthockey.com/nhl/prov...eer-stats.html

Woah....

Wait a second.

THE BEST PLAYER ON THE LEAFS IS AMERICAN, dummy!

[F30inthe6ix]

Originally Posted by sspade

Woah....

Wait a second.

THE BEST PLAYER ON THE LEAFS IS AMERICAN, dummy!

This is debatable now that Tavares is on the team.

Matthews has the highest ceiling on the Leafs, I'll admit that much.

[TeinBMW]

Originally Posted by F30inthe6ix

Lilijgren could be a stud, but he didn't look at all ready during the recent Calder Cup run. I'd say he's a year or two away still. Marleau wasn't a good signing and I'm not too happy that his contract spans three seasons. Let's hope he doesn't end up on Robidas Island before he becomes a UFA again

I have faith in the leafs in signing nylander, mitch and auston. They just need to move Marleau and Kadri and they are good! They also need some of their D prospects to come up and play.

[F30inthe6ix]

Originally Posted by TeinBMW

I have faith in the leafs in signing nylander, mitch and auston. They just need to move Marleau and Kadri and they are good! They also need some of their D prospects to come up and play.

I would keep Kadri, and let Marleau play out the duration of his deal, unless he starts playing terrible. To get a young, stud d-man, the Leafs will have to part with some talent, which starts at Nylander unfortunately.

Like yourself, I'm hoping that their D prospects develop quickly and into competent NHLers so that we don't have to seek trade options to get our back end solidified.