[chassis]

There are no blanket statements that cover all lodging, whether related to quality, experience or service, while referring to the same price level.

Take for example the Ritz in Philadelphia. Not very good. Mostly not great views, difficult access by car, lobby is uninspiring and service is typically Philly which means feigned attentiveness with underlying rudeness.

The Ritz Laguna Niguel on the other hand has stunning views, easy to access by car, great food and attentive staff. A completely different experience than in Phila at a comparable price level.

[cmyx6go]

Originally Posted by chassis

The Ritz Laguna Niguel on the other hand has stunning views, easy to access by car, great food and attentive staff. A completely different experience than in Phila at a comparable price level.

I LOVE that Ritz!

[floridaorange]

agree with OP.

[Tommy-G]

Originally Posted by OkieSnuffBox

I would ask, "Why would you go to Hawaii when you can go to a private resort in Jamaica for the same or less money?"

Mmmm Jamaica (Homer Simpson drooling)

[Manny01]

They all serve a purpose.

In your example I would much rather stay at the Ritz due to everything the property has to offer. Expansive grounds, amazing pool system, walk up beaches, bars, restaurants, spas, onsite activities for families and kids, room service and cleanings, etc. You're not paying $1K a night for a 400 sqf room, you're paying $1K a night for a 1000 acre resort. Now that's not to rip on Airbnb. Some people don't need or want that, but if I'm in Maui I'm staying at the Ritz, Grand Wailea, or Four Seasons. I was in Sedona last December and stayed at a beautiful 3000sqf AirBNB. But we had family there and the purpose wasn't to be lavished in luxury, it was to see Flagstaff, Grand Canyon, Jerome, etc. A house was better suited for that.

[PittsDriver]

We go to Maui often and always stay in a condo in Kihei far from the circus at Kaanapali. Sunny, relaxing, great snorkeling within 5 minutes... Agree on the hotels there. Might as well be on the Redneck Riviera (Florida panhandle / Alabama) coast if that's what you're doing. Nicer beaches there for hotels and way WAY cheaper.

[Torgus]

Originally Posted by Gossypiboma

The first and last time I rented an Airbnb the house had mice that ran through the kitchen, eating food in the pantry and would wake you up at night running over your bed. We had videos and pictures and Airbnb could do nothing. ANY refund has to be approved by the owner. It is solely up to them. The only thing Airbnb could do was offer us a new location, but there was nothing available.

They also allow the owner to lengthen the resolution process passed the allotted time they allow you to leave feedback for the property. Before you know what the resolution is they close the ability for you to slam the owner. In the end I was given $200 back for a $4k rental with mice.

Never again.

THIS!!!!

They do this on purpose. I have had good and bad Airbnb experiences. My hotel experiences are always the same, while be it a bit more 'boring'. Airbnbs are good like said above if you have a group and want to cook etc. When I go on vacation I usually don't want to cook. I do that every day of my life 3x a day.

Once you get burned for thousands at an Airbnb and you have no way to make it right it can really ruin you on the experience.

[Tyga11]

Originally Posted by Manny01

They all serve a purpose.

In your example I would much rather stay at the Ritz due to everything the property has to offer. Expansive grounds, amazing pool system, walk up beaches, bars, restaurants, spas, onsite activities for families and kids, room service and cleanings, etc. You're not paying $1K a night for a 400 sqf room, you're paying $1K a night for a 1000 acre resort. Now that's not to rip on Airbnb. Some people don't need or want that, but if I'm in Maui I'm staying at the Ritz, Grand Wailea, or Four Seasons. I was in Sedona last December and stayed at a beautiful 3000sqf AirBNB. But we had family there and the purpose wasn't to be lavished in luxury, it was to see Flagstaff, Grand Canyon, Jerome, etc. A house was better suited for that.

The beach at the Ritz in Kapalua sucks and it's a long walk...that is what I heard from multiple people. I did hear the pool is very nice. Overall I heard it's a very mediocre property

[cmyx6go]

Originally Posted by Tyga11

The beach at the Ritz in Kapalua sucks and it's a long walk...that is what I heard from multiple people. I did hear the pool is very nice. Overall I heard it's a very mediocre property

You heard it sucks, multiple people told you it was mediocre. So the people who have first hand experience feel differently are wrong?

I honestly don't know why you start threads asking for opinions and then dismiss anyone that doesn't agree with you.

[e90335e36m3]

Why would ANYONE stay at hotels? Most business travel doesn't allow for stays at Airbnbs. Mixing my personal and business travel has nearly earned me lifetime gold (which means 2PM checkout) and nearly platinum status (which means 4PM checkout) with Marriott. If you travel a lot internationally, then you should know that the quality of hotels it is significantly higher than is in the US and includes some very nice perks which makes them a better offering than Airbnbs in many cases, and as well better priced. I also get a lot of free nights, butlers in some cases, free nights, suites, free food. That's why I stay at hotels.

That's why I also fly with Delta with a layover, at an American hub. I'll take upgrades, miles and free flights, and the occasional ride in a Porsche between terminals.[IMG][/IMG]

[G35POPPEDMYCHERRY]

god i love internet forums

[Tyga11]

Originally Posted by cmyx6go

You heard it sucks, multiple people told you it was mediocre. So the people who have first hand experience feel differently are wrong?

I honestly don't know why you start threads asking for opinions and then dismiss anyone that doesn't agree with you.

We went to Myths of Maui which is a Luau and the couple next to us said that...we were chatting for an hour before the show started.

I'm not dismissing anyone but there is misinformation in this thread like Airbnb's are not safe, clean, etc. when that's really not the case anymore.

[MJBO]

Tried AirBnBs a number of times, was crap every time. Either the place was dirty, things didn't work, wasn't as described, or a combo of all three.

I'll take a well-rated hotel every time.

[vreihen16]

Originally Posted by Tommy-G

Mmmm Jamaica (Homer Simpson drooling)

Jamaica - Once you go, you know...never to go back to that third-world cesspool ever again!!!!!

[Tommy-G]

Originally Posted by vreihen16

Jamaica - Once you go, you know...never to go back to that third-world cesspool ever again!!!!!

I went to Sandals Montego Bay when I was 22-ish (94/95) and stayed 10 days with my then GF and it was the nicest thing I had ever done. Dont forget 24 yrs old and back in 94.
My wife will never step foot in Jamaica. She has a conception that its garbage and not enjoyable so we have conflicting views but I get it. I also am holding on to a memory of a place from almost 30 years ago

[vreihen16]

Originally Posted by Tommy-G

My wife will never step foot in Jamaica. She has a conception that its garbage and not enjoyable so we have conflicting views but I get it.

I personally saw a PCB-filled electric transformer leaking in a banana farm grove, was solicited to buy drugs before making it one block, had fake tour guides try to collect an admission fee to see Dunn's River Falls, and watched a school-aged relative of Usain Bolt chase our van running for over a mile with his hand out looking for American Dollars. Oh, and I was only there for ten hours.....

[RickFLM4]

Originally Posted by vreihen16

I personally saw a PCB-filled electric transformer leaking in a banana farm grove, was solicited to buy drugs before making it one block, had fake tour guides try to collect an admission fee to see Dunn's River Falls, and watched a school-aged relative of Usain Bolt chase our van running for over a mile with his hand out looking for American Dollars. Oh, and I was only there for ten hours.....

Can’t explore in Jamaica. Need to stay in resort and where resorts take you.

[omasou]

Originally Posted by Tyga11

Where are you coming up with this? How aren't Airbnb's safe, clean, convenient, etc? Talking to the owner means getting the door code and maybe telling them you're checked out (sound familiar?)

There are hidden fees but those are disclosed at the time of booking and include service fees, cleaning fees, etc. No different than resort charges.

How about this for convenience; walking thru the hotel lobby and waiting for an elevator and walking another 2 min to get to your room. You're not dealing with that with Airbnbs.

What's the point of room service when you have UberEats? Better and less expensive.

Dude you ask people. They provide you very specific case where they were not satisfied w/AirBnB and then your reply is to call them ignorant.

If you feel your answer is the only correct one, then why ask the question?

[OkieSnuffBox]

Originally Posted by vreihen16

I personally saw a PCB-filled electric transformer leaking in a banana farm grove, was solicited to buy drugs before making it one block, had fake tour guides try to collect an admission fee to see Dunn's River Falls, and watched a school-aged relative of Usain Bolt chase our van running for over a mile with his hand out looking for American Dollars. Oh, and I was only there for ten hours.....

Why were you in a van going somewhere if you were only there for 10 hours? Were you in Kingston?

I've been to Jamaica 4 times and none of what you are saying has been my experience. And this includes leaving the resort to get real jerk chicken and go shopping where the 25 year Appleton Rum was $110 vs $250 like on the resort.

[br438]

Originally Posted by RickFLM4

Why do people like to say “no offense” right before insulting someone else?

You gotta wind up before you throw a punch - otherwise it’s just a tickle.

[Tyga11]

Originally Posted by omasou

Dude you ask people. They provide you very specific case where they were not satisfied w/AirBnB and then your reply is to call them ignorant.

If you feel your answer is the only correct one, then why ask the question?

Read the post I was replying to. None of the pro's / con's mentioned were accurate.

You obviously have to filter by top rated / read the reviews. Just like staying in the flea bag hotel in Reno or wherever will have the same issues like a crappy Airbnb.

[dreamingat30fps]

The amount of misinformation in this thread is mind blowing. I think admins should get the FBI involved.

To tell people there are ways to travel other than by RV is just irresponsible!